top of page

KEY LABOUR LAW JUDGMENTS OF 2026 AND THEIR IMPACT

1 hour ago
9 min read

Written by Limya Kamaldien


Most employers do not begin the week expecting a labour-law problem. They begin it trying to clear a backlog, respond to queries, keep clients happy and, somewhere between all of that, manage the people who make the establishment work. Then a misunderstanding happens. A message is read in a way it was not intended. A colleague feels overlooked. A conversation escalates. Suddenly, what began as an attempt to help has become a workplace conflict, and everyone is defending their version of events.


Workplace issues rarely announce themselves. They do not arrive with a warning that says: “This may become a grievance, a disciplinary hearing or an unfair-dismissal dispute.” They usually begin with something much smaller: a miscommunication, a missed expectation, a comment taken personally, or a decision made in good faith but received badly.


The labour judgments of 2026 will not prevent every difficult conversation in 2027. But they can help employers recognise the warning signs earlier, and respond in a way that protects both the establishment and the people in it.


The cases below are not specific to the Hairdressing, Cosmetology, Beauty and Skincare Industry. Their principles, however, apply to every workplace where people are employed, managed, disciplined or required to work together.


Discipline: A fair reason still matters

In Universal Product Network (Pty) Ltd v Mbatsana NO and Others, the Labour Appeal Court considered whether gross procedural unfairness in arbitration proceedings could, on its own, make a dismissal substantively unfair. The Court confirmed that procedural unfairness does not automatically become substantive unfairness.


This does not mean employers may disregard fair procedure. It means that a dismissal must still be supported by a fair reason, credible evidence and a fair process.


For an establishment, this is relevant whenever an employee is accused of misconduct. A hairdresser accused of theft, a beauty therapist accused of inappropriate conduct, or a receptionist accused of dishonesty cannot simply be dismissed because the employer is angry, embarrassed or under pressure.


The employer must be able to show what happened, why it amounted to misconduct, and why dismissal was appropriate. The process must also allow the employee to state their case.


2027 takeaway: Keep written allegations, meeting notes, evidence, findings and reasons for the sanction. A fair decision should be explainable long after the emotion of the moment has passed.


Harassment: A comment is not always “just a joke”

In Easybranch (Pty) Ltd v Sibiya NO and Others, the Labour Court dealt with a sexual remark made by a manager to a male employee. The Court found that the remark constituted sexual harassment and that the employer was vicariously liable because it had not taken adequate steps to prevent or address such conduct. The sexual-harassment and employer-liability findings were upheld, although compensation was reduced from R100 000 to R25 000.


The case is a reminder that harassment is not limited to physical conduct or obvious threats. Words, jokes, messages and repeated comments can create a hostile working environment.


In establishments where staff work closely together, share changing areas, discuss clients and communicate through WhatsApp groups, boundaries matter. A remark made as humour may be experienced very differently by the person at whom it was directed.


Employers should not wait for a formal complaint before taking workplace culture seriously. Policies, training and clear reporting channels should exist before the incident, not after it.


2027 takeaway: Review harassment policies, train owners, managers and senior staff, and ensure employees know how to raise a concern safely.


Harassment: Responding is not optional

In N.M v Transnet SOC and Another, the Labour Court found that the employer had failed to take appropriate steps after sexual-harassment allegations were raised against a supervisor. The Court awarded compensation and a salary-related amount, while dismissing the claim for general damages.


The lesson is uncomfortable but necessary: having a policy is not the same as acting on it.


An employer cannot treat a harassment complaint as an inconvenience, a personality clash or something that will resolve itself. The complaint must be acknowledged, investigated and addressed. The complainant must also be protected from retaliation or further harm while the matter is being dealt with.


This is particularly important in smaller establishments, where relationships are close, and the alleged harasser may be a senior hairdresser, a strong performer, or someone the owner knows personally. None of those factors removes the employer’s duty to act fairly.


2027 takeaway: When a harassment concern is raised, act promptly, document the steps taken and ensure the response is consistent with the establishment’s policy.


Harassment disputes: Choose the correct forum

In Mokobane v Gauteng Department of Education, the Equality Court considered whether it had jurisdiction to hear a complaint about an employer’s handling of a sexual-harassment complaint. The Court held that the dispute arose from the employment relationship and fell within the labour-law framework rather than the Equality Court’s jurisdiction under the Promotion of Equality and Prevention of Unfair Discrimination Act.


This case does not mean employers can ignore harassment complaints because of a jurisdictional technicality. It means employees and employers must understand the appropriate route: internal grievance procedures, the CCMA, the Labour Court or, where applicable, a bargaining council.


For employers, the case is a reminder that a jurisdictional argument cannot replace proper workplace action. Even if an employee approaches the wrong forum, the employer may still face scrutiny of its investigation, policies and response.


2027 takeaway: Ensure harassment complaints are handled through a lawful and documented internal process, while understanding the correct dispute-resolution route.


Foreign nationals: fairness does not depend on nationality

The treatment of foreign nationals, asylum seekers and refugees remains a sensitive compliance issue. In Erarite (Pty) Ltd t/a Khayelitsha Superspar v CCMA and Others, the Labour Court considered a dismissal arising from a WhatsApp message posted during workplace tensions. The Court dismissed the employer’s review application and upheld the arbitration outcome that dismissal was too harsh. The appropriate sanction was a final written warning, together with three months’ compensation.


The case is a useful reminder that social-media conduct must be assessed in context. A provocative or inappropriate message may justify discipline, but it does not automatically justify dismissal.


Employers must consider the nature of the message, the workplace context, the employee’s intention, the impact on colleagues and clients, and whether a lesser sanction would be appropriate.


2027 takeaway: Update social-media policies, investigate context before acting, and ensure that any sanction is proportionate to the conduct.


Social media: Context matters

The Erarite case also highlights the growing importance of social media in the workplace. A WhatsApp message posted during workplace tensions became central to the dispute.


In the Hairdressing, Cosmetology, Beauty and Skincare Industry, social media is part of daily work. Staff may promote services, share client transformations, respond to reviews or communicate in staff groups. However, social media can also create serious employment risks.


Employers should have clear rules on:

  • Confidential client information.

  • Photographs and videos of clients.

  • Offensive, discriminatory or harassing messages.

  • Criticism of the employer, colleagues or clients.

  • Use of business social-media accounts.

  • Private messages that affect workplace relationships.


A dismissal for a social-media post should never be automatic. The employer must consider the context, the employee’s intention, the audience, the impact on the workplace and whether lesser discipline would be appropriate.


2027 takeaway: Update social-media policies and train staff on professional communication, client confidentiality and respectful online conduct.


Sick leave: Manage absence fairly

Absenteeism and sick-leave abuse remain ongoing workplace risks. Employers may require notice of absence, request medical certificates where appropriate, and address a pattern of absence through counselling, incapacity management and, where justified, discipline.


In Lewis v CCMA and Others, the Labour Court’s leave-to-appeal judgment, delivered on 23 April 2026, confirmed earlier findings concerning the employer’s cumulative conduct in handling sick leave and medical evidence. The case is not simply about an employer questioning a sick note; it concerns the broader manner in which the employer managed the situation.


Employers may manage attendance, but they must do so fairly. A medical certificate should not automatically be accepted without question, but neither should it be treated with hostility or used as a reason to punish an employee.


Employers should distinguish between genuine incapacity, misconduct and operational disruption. A medical certificate should not automatically be accepted without question, but neither should it be treated with hostility or used as a reason to punish an employee.


2027 takeaway: Implement clear attendance and sick-leave procedures, keep records, apply policies consistently and investigate suspected abuse before taking disciplinary action.


Mutual separations: Do not disguise a retrenchment

In WBHO Construction (Pty) Ltd v Masenya NO and Others, the Labour Appeal Court held that a valid, voluntary mutual separation agreement does not constitute a dismissal. The case concerned the validity of a particular agreement reached in the context of possible retrenchment.


This does not mean employers can avoid section 189 consultation simply by calling an exit a “mutual separation”. The protection depends on the agreement being genuinely voluntary and properly concluded.


An employer cannot pressure an employee to sign a separation agreement by threatening dismissal, withholding pay or making misleading promises. The employee must understand what they are agreeing to, including payment, notice, restraint provisions, references and the waiver of claims.


2027 takeaway: Use properly drafted, voluntary separation agreements. Obtain advice before presenting an exit as “mutual”, particularly where the employer is considering retrenchment.


Retrenchments: Consultation and alternatives remain critical

In National Union of Metalworkers of South Africa and Others v Industrial Oleo Chemical Products, the Constitutional Court considered what happens after a section 189A facilitation process fails in a large-scale retrenchment. The majority held that section 189A(7)(b)(ii), read with section 191(11), permits a direct referral to the Labour Court. Conciliation is not a jurisdictional precondition in those circumstances.


This does not mean employers can avoid proper consultation. It means that, once facilitation has failed, the dispute may proceed directly to the Labour Court.


Separately, in SACCAWU obo Tshokodo and Others v Mass Discounters (Pty) Ltd t/a Game and Dion Wired Stores, the Labour Court considered the substantive fairness of retrenchments and severance pay. The case reinforces that an employer must prove a genuine operational requirement, a rational response, consideration of alternatives, and fair selection criteria.


For larger establishments, spa chains, distributors and franchise networks, these cases are a warning that cost-cutting cannot be handled informally. Employers must consult, consider alternatives such as reduced hours, redeployment or voluntary measures, and apply fair selection criteria.


2027 takeaway: Before retrenching, document the business rationale, consult meaningfully, consider alternatives and ensure that the selection process is fair and defensible. If facilitation fails in a large-scale retrenchment, understand the correct route to the Labour Court.


Business rescue and AI: New risks for employers

In South African Post Office SOC Ltd (In Business Rescue) and Others v Commissioner Menzi Fakude NO and Others, the Labour Court considered the effect of business rescue on CCMA unfair-dismissal arbitrations. The Court confirmed that the business-rescue moratorium can extend to such proceedings.


Separately, the case also attracted attention because a CCMA commissioner relied on a judgment that did not exist — apparently an AI-generated case. The Labour Court criticised this reliance on unverified legal material.


These are two distinct issues: one concerns business rescue and arbitration; the other concerns the risks of relying on unverified AI-generated legal research.


For employers, this is a modern compliance warning. Artificial intelligence can assist with research, drafting and administration, but it cannot replace legal advice, verified sources or sound workplace judgement.


2027 takeaway: Employers in financial distress should understand how business rescue may affect employment disputes. Employers and HR practitioners should also verify every legal authority before relying on it.


Discipline: Employers may manage their own process

In Police and Prisons Civil Rights Union obo Khan v Minister of Police and Others, the Labour Court considered the extent of its jurisdiction in relation to specific SAPS disciplinary regulations. The Court confirmed that it has no general power to intervene in unfinished internal disciplinary proceedings without a proper legal basis.


This does not mean courts can never intervene in disciplinary processes. It means that a party must identify a specific statutory basis for intervention.


This is an employer-friendly principle. It confirms that an employer may generally run its own disciplinary process without fearing premature court interference.


However, it does not mean the process can be careless. The employer must still follow its own policy, allow a fair hearing, avoid bias, and keep proper records. The process may not be interrupted halfway, but it may still be tested afterwards.


2027 takeaway: Follow the disciplinary policy, allow the employee a fair opportunity to respond, and document every step of the process.


What this means for 2027

The common thread in these cases is not that the law has become hostile to employers. Rather, it is that the law expects employers to act fairly, consistently, and with proper evidence.


For Hairdressing, Cosmetology, Beauty and Skincare establishments, the priorities for 2027 should include:

  • Reviewing disciplinary, grievance, harassment, social-media and sick-leave policies.

  • Training owners, managers and senior staff on fair process and respectful workplace conduct.

  • Keeping contemporaneous records of warnings, meetings, investigations, client complaints and decisions.

  • Ensuring that harassment complaints trigger real action, not merely an apology.

  • Applying recruitment, immigration and work-authorisation checks consistently.

  • Using lawful and properly drafted separation agreements.

  • Following proper consultation before restructuring or retrenchment.

  • Seeking advice before dismissing an employee, particularly where immigration status, illness, social media or alleged misconduct is involved.


The establishments most likely to face disputes in 2027 will not necessarily be those with the most difficult employees. They will be those with outdated policies, inconsistent management practices and no reliable record of what happened in the workplace.


In conclusion, the 2026 judgments show that workplace fairness is not a technical exercise reserved for large corporates. It is a daily management responsibility.


Whether the issue is a staff WhatsApp message, a harassment complaint, repeated absenteeism, a proposed mutual separation, or a foreign-national employee, employers must be able to show what they knew, what they did, and why their decision was fair.


For establishments preparing for 2027, the message is straightforward: update your policies, train your people, document your decisions, and act early. Prevention is far less costly than defending an unfair-dismissal, harassment, or discrimination claim after the fact.



 
 
bottom of page